Broker Check

Long Island Educators and Public Employees

403(b) vs. 457(b): Key Differences for Long Island Educators

If your school or employer offers both a 403(b) and a 457(b), two workplace retirement savings plans, you can put money in the 403(b), the 457(b), or both. When you use both, each has its own limit, so you can generally put up to the full limit in each. In 2026 you can put $24,500 in a 403(b) and another $24,500 in a 457(b) before any catch-up (an extra amount some plans allow after a certain age), as long as both plans are open to you and your pay covers it.

If you'd like to understand how this works for your own plans, Christopher J. Vargas, LUTCF®, offers a complimentary 10-minute 403(b) checkup by video. No obligation.

Book a Complimentary 10-Minute 403(b) Checkup

The real differences show up in the catch-up rules and in what happens if you leave before 59½.

Catch-up contributions work differently in each plan. Starting at age 50, a 403(b) and a governmental 457(b) (the kind school districts and public employers use) both allow extra catch-up contributions. If you turn 60 to 63 this year, your plan may allow a higher amount. A 457(b) may also allow a special catch-up in the three years before your plan's normal retirement age, if you put in less than the maximum in earlier years. A 403(b) may allow an extra amount once you have 15 years of service with the same school or employer. Not every plan offers these options, and some can't be combined in the same year.

Leaving before 59½ works differently in each plan. Money in a governmental 457(b) generally isn't subject to the 10% early withdrawal penalty once you leave your job, at any age. The exception is money you rolled in from another type of plan or an IRA. Withdrawals from a 403(b) before 59½ usually carry that penalty. There are some exceptions, such as leaving your job in or after the year you turn 55. Pre-tax money from either plan is taxed as regular income when you take it out. It's a good idea to check with your tax preparer.

These differences matter when you decide how to use the two plans. The exact rules for your district are in your plan document, so that's the place to start. In a complimentary 10-minute 403(b) checkup, I can walk you through what yours says.

Book a Complimentary 10-Minute Checkup Book a Complimentary Atlas VirtualWealth Session

No obligation.

Meet in Hauppauge or by video through Atlas VirtualWealth.


Each Plan Has Its Own Limit

You can contribute to the 403(b), the 457(b), or both. When you use both, each has its own limit, so money in one doesn't count against the other. Inside each plan, Traditional (before-tax) and Roth (after-tax) share that plan's one limit.

Leaving Before 59½ Works Differently

Taking taxable money out of a 403(b) early can come with a 10% extra tax. A governmental 457(b) generally doesn't add that extra tax once you leave your job, although income tax still applies to traditional balances.

Check What Your Plan Allows

Not every plan offers Roth contributions, loans, the 15-year catch-up or the 457(b) special catch-up. Your plan document lists which of these you can use.


How the Two Plans Compare in 2026

These lines describe a governmental 457(b), the kind school districts and public employers use. It's a good idea to confirm each line against your own plan before you change how much comes out of your paycheck.

Who it is for

403(b)

Public school employees, and employees of many nonprofits, hospitals, and churches, when that employer offers a 403(b).

457(b)

State and local government employees, including many school districts, when the employer offers a governmental 457(b). A tax-exempt 457(b) is a different plan, usually for a smaller group, and not every rule on this page applies to it.

2026 contribution limit

403(b)

$24,500, or 100% of your includible pay (the pay the IRS counts for this limit) if that is less. It's separate from the 457(b) limit.

457(b)

$24,500, separate from the 403(b). Money you put into the 403(b) doesn't reduce it.

Age 50 to 59 or 64+

403(b)

Up to $8,000 more in the 403(b) if the plan allows it. That's $32,500 in the 403(b).

457(b)

You can also put the same $8,000 more in the 457(b), if it's a governmental 457(b) and the plan allows it. That's another $32,500 in the 457(b), on top of the 403(b).

Ages 60 to 63

403(b)

$11,250 instead of the $8,000 in the 403(b), if the plan allows it. That's $35,750 in the 403(b). The higher amount replaces the $8,000 rather than stacking on top of it.

457(b)

You can also use the same $11,250 in place of the $8,000 in a governmental 457(b), if the plan allows it. That's another $35,750 in the 457(b), on top of the 403(b).

Special catch-up

403(b)

With 15 years of service at the same eligible employer, such as one public school system, the 403(b) may allow up to $3,000 more this year. This catch-up is for the 403(b) only. The lifetime cap is $15,000. The amount is the lesser of $3,000, what is left of that $15,000, or $5,000 times your years of service there minus what you already put into that employer's plan. It isn't automatic.

457(b)

In the three years before normal retirement age under that 457(b) plan, you may be able to put in up to $49,000, or the basic limit plus unused basic limit from earlier years, whichever is less. That date is the one in the 457(b) document. It isn't your pension retirement date unless the document says so. You generally can't use this and the 457(b) age-based catch-up in the same year. The 403(b) age catch-up can still apply that year.

Employer money

403(b)

An employer contribution usually doesn't use up the $24,500. Employee and employer dollars together are generally capped at $72,000 in 2026, or at your includible pay if that is lower.

457(b)

An employer contribution usually does count toward the 457(b)'s $24,500, because your money and the employer's money in the 457(b) share that plan's limit. In many public 457(b) plans, all the money comes from you, not your employer.

Your pension

403(b)

What you pay into your pension doesn't use up the $24,500. The pension and the 403(b) are separate, and having a pension doesn't mean you can skip the 403(b) fee list.

457(b)

A pension contribution doesn't use up the 457(b) either. The 457(b) is extra savings beside the pension check, not a second pension.

Traditional or Roth

403(b)

Many plans offer both. Traditional and Roth in the same 403(b) share that plan's one limit. Traditional goes in pre-tax, and Roth goes in after-tax.

457(b)

A governmental 457(b) may offer Roth if the document allows it. A tax-exempt 457(b) generally doesn't. Traditional and Roth in the same 457(b) still share that plan's one limit.

Leaving before 59½

403(b)

A 10% extra tax can apply to many taxable withdrawals. Leaving your job in or after the year you turn 55 can be an exception, if the money stays in the plan. Income tax still applies to traditional balances.

457(b)

After you leave your job, a governmental 457(b) generally doesn't add that 10% extra tax, at any age. Income tax still applies to traditional balances. Money that came in as a rollover from an IRA or another plan can still face the extra tax.

While you are still working

403(b)

Some plans allow a loan, a hardship withdrawal, or a withdrawal once you reach 59½ while you're still working. A hardship can include tuition or a home purchase if the document says so.

457(b)

Some governmental plans allow loans. A withdrawal while you are still working is usually an unforeseeable emergency, unless the document also allows one at 59½. Tuition and a home purchase often don't qualify.

Fees and choices

403(b)

Your employer has a list of approved companies you can open a 403(b) with. Some offer annuities and some offer mutual funds. Before you sign up, ask what you'd pay each year, including the fund expenses, any insurance charges on an annuity, any charge for moving your money out early, and any advisory fee.

457(b)

The 457(b) has its own list of investment options. It isn't always cheaper than a 403(b), so ask for the same list of fees before you put more of your paycheck into it.

Rollover

403(b)

A 403(b) can often be rolled over to an IRA or another workplace plan after you leave. A rollover isn't automatically the right move.

457(b)

A governmental 457(b) can also be rolled over. If you roll it into an IRA, a withdrawal before 59½ can generally face the 10% extra tax, even if you've already left your job. It's worth understanding whether a rollover fits before you move the money.

New York tax

403(b)

New York taxes 403(b) withdrawals differently from your state teachers' pension. Once you're 59½, New York may let you exclude up to $20,000 a year of certain pension and annuity income. Your tax preparer can tell you how this applies to you.

457(b)

Governmental 457(b) withdrawals aren't treated like your pension either. Some 457(b) payments may count toward the same $20,000 exclusion, but that doesn't mean the whole withdrawal is tax-free in New York.

Later required withdrawals

403(b)

Traditional balances generally require withdrawals later. If you were born 1951 through 1959, the age is 73. If you were born in 1960 or later, it's 75. If you're still working for the employer that sponsors the plan, you may be able to wait until you retire, if the plan allows it. Roth 403(b) balances generally don't require withdrawals during your lifetime.

457(b)

The same ages apply to traditional governmental 457(b) balances. You may also be able to wait while you still work for that employer, if the plan allows it. Roth amounts in the plan generally don't require withdrawals while you're alive.


Common Mix-Ups to Check First

These are the mix-ups people run into most often before they change how much goes in through payroll. The comparison above covers the rest.

Your Pension Isn't Your 403(b)

What you pay into your pension doesn't count against your $24,500, because the pension and the workplace account are separate.

The 15-Year Rule Isn't Automatic

Reaching year 15 doesn't raise your limit by itself. The 403(b) document has to allow it, and anything you've already used under that rule reduces what's left.

The 457(b) Catch-Up Uses Its Own Date

The special 457(b) catch-up is tied to normal retirement age in that plan. It isn't tied to your pension date unless the document says so.

Rolling Money Into an IRA Can Change the Taxation

After you leave your employer, you can usually take money out of a governmental 457(b) before age 59½ without the 10% early withdrawal tax. If you roll that money into an IRA, the IRA rules apply instead, so the 10% tax can apply to withdrawals before 59½.

You Can't Judge the Cost by the Plan Name

It helps to ask for the fee list on the company or investment menu you'd actually use, since a 457(b) isn't automatically the lower-cost account.


How Much You Can Set Aside in 2026

These are the amounts you can put in, and they're capped at your includible pay. Employer money on a 457(b) usually counts against the number, while employer money on a 403(b) usually doesn't.

Under 50

403(b) $24,500

457(b) $24,500

Both $49,000

Age 50 to 59 or 64+

This includes the $8,000 catch-up in each plan, if each plan allows it.

403(b) $32,500

457(b) $32,500

Both $65,000

Ages 60 to 63

The $11,250 replaces the $8,000 in each plan. It doesn't stack on top of it.

403(b) $35,750

457(b) $35,750

Both $71,500

For example, if you're under 50 and your employer offers both plans, you could put $24,500 in the 403(b) and $24,500 in the 457(b), for $49,000 in total, as long as your pay covers it. If your plan allows the 403(b) 15-year catch-up and you still have room under the $15,000 lifetime cap, you can add up to $3,000 on the 403(b) only.

In the last 3 years before your 457(b) plan's normal retirement age, the 457(b) special catch-up may let you put in up to $49,000, or $24,500 plus the room you didn't use in earlier years, whichever is less. You use it instead of the 457(b) age-based catch-up, not on top of it.

The 403(b) age catch-up can still apply in that year.

If you are 50 or older and your 2025 Social Security wages (W-2 Box 3) from that employer were over $150,000, your 2026 age-based catch-up generally has to go in as Roth. The special 3-year catch-up isn't affected.

If your plan has no Roth option, you may not be able to make that catch-up in 2026, and your payroll office can confirm. For how this affects your taxes, check with your tax preparer.

Figures follow the IRS cost-of-living adjustments for 2026. You can read the IRS pages on 403(b) contribution limits, 457(b) contribution limits and the IRS 2026 limits announcement


If You Can Only Fund One Plan

If one of the plans has a match, it usually makes sense to start there, so you don't pass up that employer money. If neither plan matches and you might leave before 59½, the 457(b) is usually the more flexible account because of the withdrawal rule above, and you can put the rest in the 403(b).

This is a general starting point, not a recommendation for your situation. Your pension, your spouse's retirement plan, or plans to buy a home could change what makes sense for you.

Book a Complimentary 10-Minute Checkup

No obligation.


Choosing Traditional or Roth

Traditional

Traditional money goes in before tax, which lowers your taxable income this year. Withdrawals in retirement are taxed as ordinary income.

Roth

Roth money goes in after tax, and withdrawals, including earnings, can generally be tax-free once it has been five tax years since your first Roth contribution to that plan and you're 59½ or older or disabled. Your plan has to offer Roth.

Either way, it's a choice about when you pay tax. Using both Traditional and Roth doesn't double your room under the limit.


How These Plans Fit With Your Pension

A Long Island public school teacher's pension is separate from these accounts. The 403(b) and the 457(b) are savings accounts in addition to that check, not a replacement for it.

You open these accounts through your employer, using your district's approved list of companies, and many Long Island districts use an outside administrator for that list. State employees often have a statewide 457(b), and a school district or town may offer its own, but those aren't automatically the same plan.

Meet in Hauppauge or by video through Atlas VirtualWealth.


What to Expect When You Book

1. The Checkup Takes About 10 Minutes

You pick a time that works for you, and you meet with Christopher by video.

2. Go Over Your Plan Together

The conversation covers your fees, who your plan provider is, and whether you're using one plan or both. If you'd like more time than the checkup, you can book a complimentary Atlas VirtualWealth session, which is a personal virtual planning conversation that takes about 45 minutes.

3. You Leave With Questions for Payroll

You'll leave with a short list of questions for payroll. No money is moved on that call.


Related Pages

Open the Educator Benefits Checklist

This walks through the 403(b), the 457(b), the pension, and the insurance that's already in your paycheck.

Open 403(b) at a Glance

This is the short version of the 403(b). It covers limits, fees, and what to ask before you sign up with a company on your district's list.

Understand How 457(b) Plans Work

This is the companion page for the governmental 457(b) many Long Island districts offer beside the 403(b).

Understand How to Open Both Plans

This explains how payroll, the vendor list (the companies your district lets you use), and Traditional or Roth get set up.

Understand Pension Options

This covers the pension payment choices Long Island teachers have alongside these accounts.

Understand Planning Fees

Here's what a planning fee covers, and what it does not, before you book anything longer than the checkup.


Frequently Asked Questions

Can you put money in both a 403(b) and a 457(b) in the same year?

If your employer offers both, yes. You can contribute to the 403(b), the 457(b), or both. When you use both, each has its own limit, so you can generally put the full amount in each. In 2026 that's $24,500 in the 403(b) and $24,500 in the 457(b), before any catch-up. Your pay still has to cover it.

Does a 457(b) share a limit with a 403(b)?

No. A governmental 457(b) has its own contribution limit, and your 403(b) money doesn't count against it. If your employer offers both, you can generally put up to the full limit in each.

What happens if you leave before age 59½?

On a 403(b), a 10% extra tax can apply to many taxable withdrawals before 59½. Leaving your job in or after the year you turn 55 can be an exception, if the money stays in that plan.

On a governmental 457(b), that 10% extra tax generally doesn't apply after you leave your job, at any age. Ordinary income tax still applies to traditional balances. If you roll the money into an IRA, that treatment can change.

Can you use every catch-up in the same year?

On a 403(b), the 15-year service catch-up and the age-based catch-up can both apply if the plan allows them. Amounts above the regular limit count toward the 15-year catch-up first.

On a 457(b), you generally can't use the special three-year catch-up and the 457(b) age-based catch-up in the same year. Your 403(b) age-based catch-up can still apply that year.

Do you get two limits if you use both Traditional and Roth?

No. Traditional and Roth in the same plan share that plan's one limit. Traditional dollars go in before tax, and withdrawals are taxed as ordinary income. Roth dollars go in after tax, and withdrawals, including earnings, can generally be tax-free once it has been five tax years since your first Roth contribution to that plan and you're 59½ or older or disabled. The plan has to offer Roth.

How do you open a 403(b) or a 457(b)?

You open them through your employer, using your district's approved list of companies, and payroll sends the money. A district plan isn't an IRA you open on your own.

Is the checkup a sales pitch?

No. The complimentary 10-minute 403(b) checkup is a short review of fees, choices, and the next questions for payroll. If you'd like a longer planning conversation, that's a personal Atlas VirtualWealth session.

How do these plans fit with a pension?

A Long Island public school teacher's pension is separate from these accounts. The 403(b) and the 457(b) are extra savings beside that check, not a replacement. Your pension contribution doesn't use up either contribution limit.

Is a 457(b) always cheaper than a 403(b)?

No. The cost depends on the choice in front of you. It's worth reading the fund expenses, any insurance charges on an annuity, any charge for moving your money out early, and any advisory fee on the approved list, because the plan type doesn't set the price.

Does New York tax a withdrawal the same way as a pension?

Not always. New York handles your state teachers' pension separately from a 403(b) or a governmental 457(b). Once you're 59½, New York may let you exclude up to $20,000 a year of certain pension and annuity income. Your tax preparer can tell you how this applies to you.


Book Your Complimentary Checkup

Christopher spends 10 minutes with you by video on the 403(b), the 457(b), or both. If you'd like more time, you can set up a personal Atlas VirtualWealth session.

Book a Complimentary 10-Minute Checkup Book a Complimentary Atlas VirtualWealth Session Call (631) 389-2358

No obligation.

Atlas Benefits Advisor

Christopher J. Vargas, LUTCF®

President & Chief Benefits Strategist

410 Motor Parkway, 2nd Floor, Hauppauge, NY 11788

Call (631) 389-2358

Text (631) 904-0901

cvargas@atlasbenefitsadvisor.com

Hours: Monday to Friday, 9:00 a.m. to 5:00 p.m.; Saturday by appointment only

Have a Question?

Thank you!
Oops!

Working with a Financial Professional

Working with a financial professional can be one of the most important decisions you make. Check out this helpful guide to learn exactly why this may be your next best move.